Bug #12424
closed
- Status changed from New to In Progress
- Assignee changed from Nikos Minadakis to Yannis Marketakis
The value in the GRSF KB is correct, so this is an issue appeared during the publishing.
- Status changed from In Progress to Feedback
- % Done changed from 0 to 90
This issue appeared because there were some of the identified categories missing (not fully exploited in this case).
I've updated the list of keywords that are expected to appear under this category (show below).
- Fully exploited
- Overexploited
- Moderately exploited
- Uncertain
- Underexploited
- Depleted
- Recovering
- Not fully exploited
- Uncertain/Not assessed
Currently, the catalogue is down for maintenance. As soon as it is up, I will re-upload the record (both the legacy and the GRSF one) to make sure that they are fine.
I thought the categories were transparent to the process and received blindly whatever is in the source databases (legacy records).
However since it is not like that we need to add in the list also the following:
Overfished
Not Overfished
Maximally sustainably fished
Underfished
Aureliano Gentile wrote:
I thought the categories were transparent to the process and received blindly whatever is in the source databases (legacy records).
We can do that. However, when we refer to categories we usually expect that they are collected from a controlled vocabulary.
I am fine leaving it as a free text field. If you feel more comfortable this way I can change it. Just let me know.
The FAO state of a stock is based on a controlled vocabulary, which however it changes across time. The above new items I provided are coming from SOFIA 2018 http://www.fao.org/3/I9540EN/i9540en.pdf (page 40). These new values will be adopted gradually by the stakeholders, hence the older values are still in use and gradually they will fade away. But it may take years!
So, it is much better to have a controlled vocabulary and I am fine as long as all terms are there. If you want to diminish the burden of the maintenance, then just take whatever is coming for that field. I am fine with both approach.
- Status changed from Feedback to In Progress
- % Done changed from 90 to 70
OK. Then I suggest to keep the controlled vocabulary for now and we'll see in the future if we want to relax this constraint by making it a free text field.
I will update the controlled vocabulary accordingly.
- Blocks Bug #12906: Update "problematic" records in the GRSF admin catalog added
- Status changed from In Progress to Closed
- % Done changed from 70 to 100
Also available in: Atom
PDF
Updated by 
Updated by 
